The Esoteric Section or Esoteric School of Theosophy – begun by H. P. Blavatsky in 1888-1889, assisted by William Q. Judge – was the largely hidden (though its existence was not a secret and any member could apply for entrance) “inner body” of the Theosophical Society, and intended be the “heart and soul” of that exoteric or outer or public Society.
It was not supposed to be a type of “club” or “clique” but rather an extremely serious and actual outpost of the Trans-Himalayan Esoteric School, i.e. of that Brotherhood of Masters most closely involved with HPB and the establishment of the Society.
If members would commit to serving wholeheartedly the great Theosophical Cause by vowing to defend, protect, and promote it, and if they were serious about wishing to embark on the Path towards chelaship/discipleship, as well as being willing to abide by the numerous rules of conduct, they would be permitted to receive teachings given by HPB which were not publicly accessible and were of a more esoteric and occultly oriented kind than found in her public writings, which are ultimately only semi-esoteric.
HPB was the first Outer Head of the School. The title is derived from the fact that there was an Inner Head (although this specific term was rarely, if ever, used; HPB herself simply used the terms “Head” and “Real Head”), for whom the Outer Head was the mouthpiece and accessible representative or agent. Conscious, direct contact with the Inner Head could only be reached by a member through successful attainment of chelaship, or at least by coming close to such attainment. The Inner Head of the Theosophical Society’s Esoteric School was the Master Morya, the Teacher and Guru of H. P. Blavatsky.
After HPB’s death in 1891, it was deduced that William Judge and Annie Besant were her choice to jointly lead the Esoteric Section. Judge – who Besant initially wholeheartedly supported and recognised as a senior, wiser, and more esoterically authoritative figure than herself – was based in New York, USA, and Besant, who had only been involved with Theosophy for two years by that time, was situated in London, England.
After a few years, it became apparent that one or two disgruntled members or ex-members had been leaking parts of HPB’s Esoteric Instructions to the general public. But in 1897, the year after William Judge passed away, Annie Besant published extensive sections and excerpts from all five of HPB’s Instructions, in a slightly edited form, in what she claimed to be the “Third Volume” of “The Secret Doctrine.” One could argue that as “The Theosophical Society – Adyar,” to which she belonged, was now an entirely independent entity with just one Esoteric Section and one Outer Head – namely herself – she was within her rights to make all those things public, since she technically had the organisational authority to do so. Many other Theosophists felt differently, however, and the United Lodge of Theosophists in particular has repeatedly accused her of deliberately – and spiritually unlawfully – breaking the solemn pledge of secrecy to which she had committed herself in the name of the Higher Self when joining the School under HPB.
Since that time, virtually all of the original esoteric material – from both HPB and Judge – has become public and easily accessible, usually due to historians and scholars who believe the world should have unhindered access to it. Today, the majority of Theosophists, with the ULT being virtually the only exception, do not see any problem with such documents and teachings being completely public and freely available, as well as freely and openly discussed in Theosophical circles.
We will explore that in this article and will see that even if we believe Besant did not have the right – ethically and occultly – to do what she did, the situation is still not as straightforward as some might imagine. It is, so to speak, quite “messy.”
~ * ~
“PUBLICATION WILL DO NO HARM”
“Publication by others of the Instructions relieves no one from the pledge of secrecy. Such a publication will do no harm, as the Instructions tend to promote spiritual growth and arouse high aspiration: on their face they do not divulge occult secrets, although deep students can, by looking beneath the surface, find in them that which H.P.B. wished to impart.” (E.S.T. Order signed by William Q. Judge and Annie Besant, dated July-August 1894)
“Again, it is known that many members regard every word of the [Esoteric Section] papers somewhat like a fetish, thinking that they are all secret and unattainable, whereas anyone who has read much knows that many parts are quite exoteric. Such parts were used by H.P.B. for the purpose of explanation. But as many look at every word as secret it is necessary now to hit on a plan for so arranging the matter that members who do not know what is common to literature may be plainly so informed; and also that certain esoteric points may be left blank for oral communication. . . . The changes will however be a matter of slow work as Mrs. Besant is now far away and I am to be away myself for some time attending the convention of the T.S.” (E.S.T. document signed by William Q. Judge, March 1894; Note: These proposed changes were never implemented.)
“Ever since the E.S. was formed I had nothing but worry with it in America & in America alone. I have here in England about 80, & abroad 25 Esotericists, 35 in the London Gupta Vidya [i.e. the London-based Group of the Esoteric Section/School] alone, – & not one ever since “M.C.” [i.e. Mabel Collins] left, – not one has ever given trouble or turned traitor, or gave any difficulty whatever. This is why being sure of these I teach them the real thing as extras [i.e. a reference to the 12 specially selected members of the London E.S. Group, who HPB gathered together as the “Inner Group” of the Esoteric Section and gave more advanced teachings than to the rest; the Inner Group was by invitation only and not spoken of publicly, whereas any Theosophical Society member who so wished could apply to join the Esoteric Section], sending to America only that which if even printed will really do no harm, as they do not possess the last key to correspondences & tattvic mysteries [i.e. in other words, the general printed Esoteric Instructions cannot cause any harm unless one possesses further and deeper knowledge than they provide].” (H. P. Blavatsky, Letter to William Q. Judge, 9th February 1890)
DID W. Q. JUDGE “RELEASE ALL THE INSTRUCTIONS FROM SECRECY” LIKE SOME CLAIM?
“To the members of the E.S.T.
“COMPANIONS AND FRIENDS: – In accordance with order received from the Master, I hereby declare that Instructions I, II and III of this School are no longer secret, with the following exceptions:
(a) The A. E.
(b) The plain and colored Diagrams and Plates and their explanations.
(c) The Correspondences.
(d) The Word and sacred formula.
“The above four are not relieved from privacy and cannot be discussed with non-members.
“The books should not be shown to non-members. . . . Freedom of use or discussion of Instructions I, II and III should not go publicly to the extent of giving out the books or reading from them; but references to them and their contents, with absolute regard to the exceptions noted, is permissible.
“If the source of statements or ideas derived directly from those three Instructions be asked for, it may be stated that they are from the teachings given out in the E.S.T. which it is now permitted to make public.
“Fraternally yours,
WILLIAM Q. JUDGE.” (E.S.T. Order, dated 3rd December 1894; this followed by one month Judge’s important E.S. circular letter headed “BY MASTER’S DIRECTION” in which he deposed Annie Besant from her joint headship of the E.S. due to various serious infringements of esoteric principles; naturally, Besant and her supporters did not accept this and so the Esoteric School split in two, the outer Theosophical Society splitting six months later. The above-quoted Order was thus received and followed solely by those E.S. members who were loyal to Judge.)
So that we may be accurate regarding what this Order was actually permitting and prohibiting (seeing as it is often misquoted or selectively misremembered) let us summarise it:
(1) Parts of Instructions I, II, and III were released from secrecy. This did not extend to Instructions IV and V, which were not even mentioned in this document.
(2) Four key or fundamental components of those first three Instructions were “not relieved from privacy” and not authorised to “be discussed with non-members.”
(3) Those four things were the parts of the Instructions which people most like to talk about: the Auric Egg or Auric Envelope, all the diagrams and plates (i.e. “both plain and colored”) including their explanations, all the esoteric correspondences (i.e. the connections between human Principles, planets, colours, sounds, parts of the body, etc.), and the Sacred Word and that which is termed the “sacred formula.” One was to retain “absolute regard to the exceptions noted.”
(4) The release specified that it was still not permissible to publicly read out anything from the books of Instructions, nor to share the books in any way with non-members of the E.S.
(5) “References to them and their contents, with absolute regard to the exceptions noted, is permissible . . . [as are] statements or ideas derived directly from those three Instructions.”
One could argue that if one factors those four key restrictions into account, there is actually hardly anything left of Instructions I, II, and III. It seems that what was being released was primarily their more exoteric content which Judge had referred to in the March 1894 document we quoted from earlier.
EXAMPLES OF THE ESOTERIC IN THE EXOTERIC
in the writings of H. P. Blavatsky
“Theosophists of the E. S. who know the transposition made of Atmâ and the part taken by the auric prototype, . . .” (“The Theosophical Glossary” p. 137, Entry for “Hay-yah”)
Here HPB takes a detail which was originally reserved solely for the E.S. members and reveals to Theosophists at large as well as to the general public that in teachings deeper than those found in the exoteric Theosophical literature, Atma or Atman – the highest Principle in the classification of the sevenfold nature of man – is replaced by a Principle designated “Auric.” Even in “The Key to Theosophy” (p. 93, 119) and elsewhere, HPB had made such statements as: “We include Atma among the human “principles” in order not to create additional confusion. In reality it is no “human” but the universal absolute principle of which Buddhi, the Soul-Spirit, is the carrier.” “Atma . . . ought not to be called, in truth, a “human” principle at all.”
The specific term “the auric envelope” appears in “The Secret Doctrine” Vol. 2, p. 684.
“The astral form clothing the Monad was surrounded [i.e. in the earliest Root Races], as it still is, by its egg-shaped sphere of aura, . . . the egg of surrounding aura.” (“The Secret Doctrine” Vol. 2, p. 117)
In light of the above two quotes in the exoteric literature, authorised by HPB herself, one could hardly justifiably object to public usage of the terms “Auric Envelope” or even “Auric Egg.” The latter is the natural abbreviated equivalent of “egg-shaped sphere of aura” or “egg of surrounding aura.”
“The colour of the fourth Principle in man — Kâma, the seat of desires is represented red.” (“The Theosophical Glossary” p. 276, Entry for “Red Colour”)
“Lucifer is “the bright morning star” [i.e. Venus], a well known symbol in Revelations, and, as a planet, corresponds to the EGO [i.e. the Higher Manas principle in man, the permanent, self-conscious Individuality].” (“The Theosophical Glossary” p. 76, Entry for “Chandra-vansa”)
“A consensus of allegorical statements . . . will be found to corroborate and justify the Esoteric teaching, that Yama-Yamî is the symbol of the dual Manas, in one of its mystical meanings. For instance, Yama-Yamî is always represented of a green colour and clothed with red, and as dwelling in a palace of copper and iron. Students of Occultism know to which of the human “principles” the green and the red colours, and by correspondence the iron and copper, are to be applied.” (“The Theosophical Glossary” p. 376, Entry for “Yama”)
Higher and Lower Manas have metaphysical correspondences and connections with green (clothed with red) and there are also correspondences here with the metals iron and copper. We already know from another “Glossary” entry quoted above, that red is the colour of Kama. So that one of the twofold Manas which is represented as green-red must be the Kama-Manas, also known as Lower Manas.
But the most extensive “exotericising” by HPB of the esoteric correspondences from her private material was done by her in “Lucifer” magazine, in a series of footnotes to an article titled “The Alchemists.”
This was in December 1889, over a year after she had founded the Esoteric Section and declared such details as these to be confidential esoteric secrets. Although she (nor William Judge) never directly informed E.S. members that they were no longer bound to secrecy regarding these correspondences, the fact that she herself – the Head of the Esoteric Section – made them public knowledge in public statements in a public magazine, which anyone and everyone – Theosophist or not – can access, read, discuss, and comment upon, presumably amounts to declaring them exoteric. The members of her Esoteric School committed themselves to keeping secret any information received from the School with the exception of any such information that may at various times “be declared exoteric.” Of course, there is a difference between something being declared exoteric by one who has the right and authority to do so, and something being merely made exoteric by someone consciously or carelessly violating a sacred pledge of secrecy that they have taken.
In the December 1889 “Lucifer” we find HPB writing:
“. . . the Linga-Sarira which corresponds to the violet colour as a compound of red (Kama-rupa) and indigo dark blue of the upper Manas . . .”
“The transcendent red or golden orange of the Sun [i.e. which directly relates to Prana, as indicated in “The Secret Doctrine”; orange is also hinted to be the colour of Prana in the section on sleep and dreams in “Transactions of The Blavatsky Lodge”]. This must not be confused with the scarlet Kama-rupan redness. Have in mind the colour of the Yogi-robes, the colour of which is symbolical of the sun of life and of human lifeblood.
“. . . This “philosophical Vine” is the lower Manas merged at last and reunited to its higher Alter Ego, when it begins to bring forth the green clusters of the “true Vine” for the Husbandman, the “Father” or Higher Self (Atma-Buddhi); vide John, xv. . . .
“The green of the lower Manas, the Animal Soul, will be “overcome with azure” or the reflection of the Higher (which is Indigo), into their aura which is blue, when pure.”
Putting all this information together, we can see that HPB has publicly revealed all these esoteric colour correspondences:
Red – Kama (Rupa)
Orange – Prana
Yellow – [not given here]
Green – Lower Manas
Blue – Aura (Auric Envelope, etc.)
Indigo – Higher Manas
Violet – Linga Sharira
We noted earlier from “The Key to Theosophy” and “The Theosophical Glossary” that Atman is, properly speaking, not to be counted as an individual human Principle, since it is purely universal, and that the Auric Principle takes its place. This being so, it should be obvious by means of simple deduction that the colour yellow must correspond to the only immortal Principle not directly named or identified here: Buddhi, the Spiritual Soul, the radiation of Atman, the Christ-Light. Incidentally, Buddhi is also associated with the planet Mercury in “The Secret Doctrine” and elsewhere.
As for “The Word and sacred formula” which Judge listed in 1894 as one of the esoteric topics not released from secrecy, the basic details of what these refer to had in fact already been made public by H. P. Blavatsky. On p. 44 of “The Theosophical Glossary” one can find:
“Aum (Sk.). The sacred syllable; the triple-lettered unit; hence the trinity [i.e. Atma-Buddhi-Manas] in One.”
“Avalokiteswara (Sk.). “The on-looking Lord.” In the exoteric interpretation, he is Padmapâni (the lotus bearer and the lotus-born) in Tibet, the first divine ancestor of the Tibetans, the complete incarnation or Avatar of Avalokiteswara; but in esoteric philosophy Avaloki, the “on-looker”, is the Higher Self, while Padmapâni is the Higher Ego or Manas. The mystic formula “Om mani padme hum” is specially used to invoke their joint help [i.e. the help of one’s Higher Self and Higher Ego, which would really amount to Atma-Buddhi-Manas functioning as one].”
And on p. 239-240:
“Om or Aum (Sk.). A mystic syllable, the most solemn of all words in India. It is “an invocation, a benediction, an affirmation and a promise” and it is so sacred, as to be indeed the word at low breath of occult, primitive masonry. No one must be near when the syllable is pronounced for a purpose. This word is usually placed at the beginning of sacred Scriptures, and is prefixed to prayers. It is a compound of three letters a, u, m, . . . In esoteric philosophy these are the three sacred fires, or the “triple fire” in the Universe and Man, besides many other things. Occultly, this “triple fire” represents the highest Tetraktys also, . . . This monosyllable is called Udgîtta, and is sacred with both Brahmins and Buddhists.”
~ * ~
Even in the literature of the United Lodge of Theosophists, which is traditionally considered the most conservative of all Theosophical associations, we find writers such as Robert Crosbie, B. P. Wadia, and anonymous contributors to magazines such as “The Theosophical Movement,” occasionally making reference to things from HPB’s esoteric teachings which are not even covered by or permitted in WQJ’s 1894 release from secrecy. Crosbie and Wadia speak of the “Three Hypostases of Atman” or “Triple Atma,” the development of the double spinal cord, and (in Wadia’s case) numerous details regarding the pineal gland and pituitary gland.
Though this was only done very occasionally by them, to a completely impartial observer it would appear hypocritical for the ULT to maintain that it is only permissible for them to do so, but not for other Theosophical groups or writers. If one has the right to do so, surely all have the right to do so, unless some very compelling evidence can be provided to the contrary?
To conclude, the whole matter is nowhere near as clear as some might imagine.
It is complicated even further when we consider that there are multiple Theosophical organisations and offshoots who claim that they have had contact with the Masters since the time of Blavatsky and Judge, and that the Masters now treat HPB’s esoteric material as exoteric.
Those could indeed all be false or deluded claims but they point to the question of how one could reliably and definitively know the truth of the matter on this point. Some say “If the Masters had now released everything from secrecy, They would have made sure to let us know, in writing.” But those Masters are surely aware that some Theosophists, especially among some of the most earnest and devoted, will automatically dismiss and reject any 20th or 21st century communication purporting to come from Masters as “false” and especially if it appears to in any way differ from the Theosophical authorities of 130+ years ago. So how could the Masters make anything known in a categorical and collectively accepted way to Theosophists today?
Considering that a whole New Cycle (in fact, multiple new cycles almost simultaneously) dawned for mankind in 1898 LINK, it would be very surprising – though of course not absolutely impossible – if the Masters’ intentions and plans for Theosophists and the work of the Theosophical Movement had not changed one iota since the time of H. P. Blavatsky and William Q. Judge. We do not even find anything in the writings of HPB and WQJ to support such a notion of Master-sanctioned Theosophical stasis.
Krishna’s famous advice to Arjuna in the Bhagavad Gita is relevant in all this: “Act as seems best to you.” Clearly, if one happens to have taken a pledge to keep certain things secret, one should do so, but even then one should be aware that – as we have demonstrated over the course of this article – nothing is absolutely “black and white” or perfectly clearcut. Intuition, and not only intellect, will always assist us in knowing what to do and how to do it.
~ * ~
This article may have raised more questions about various things. Please make use of the site search function (the magnifying glass symbol at the top of the page) and visit the Articles page to see the complete list of over 400 articles covering all aspects of Theosophy and the Theosophical Movement.
~ BlavatskyTheosophy.com ~

